What Is Lake Effect Snow? How It Forms and Where It Hits

32

Key Points

  • Lake effect snow forms when cold, dry air crosses the open, relatively warm water of a large lake, picks up heat and moisture, and drops it as narrow bands of snow downwind.
  • The National Weather Service (NWS) says these bands can produce 2 to 3 inches of snow per hour or more, while the sun may shine a mile or two away.
  • Forecasters look for an unfrozen lake, a large lake-to-air temperature contrast (at least 13 degrees Celsius), enough moisture and wind blowing across a long stretch of open water.
  • In New York, NWS offices issue a Lake Effect Snow Warning for 7 inches or more in 12 hours or 9 inches or more in 24 hours.
  • The season ramps up by mid-November. Two of Buffalo’s most extreme storms, in 2014 and 2022, hit in the week before Thanksgiving.

What is lake effect snow? It is snow made by a lake. When frigid air flows over a large body of water that is still unfrozen and comparatively warm, the lake heats and moistens the lowest layer of air. That air rises, builds clouds and drops snow on the land downwind, often in narrow bands that can bury one town while the next one sees sunshine.

The Great Lakes are the classic U.S. example, and late fall is when the season begins. Here is how it works, where it hits and what the alerts mean, based on National Weather Service and NOAA guidance.

What is lake effect snow?

The NWS glossary defines lake effect snow as “snow showers that are created when cold, dry air passes over a large warmer lake, such as one of the Great Lakes, and picks up moisture and heat.” The NWS adds that the cold air often originates in Canada and that the process is common across the Great Lakes region in late fall and winter.

The difference from an ordinary snowstorm is the engine. NOAA’s National Severe Storms Laboratory (NSSL) notes that lake effect storms are not low pressure systems. As NWS Duluth puts it, lake effect snow develops over open water and is then blown onto land.

How lake effect snow forms

  1. Cold air arrives. Cold, dry air moves over the Great Lakes, usually behind a cold front.
  2. The lake adds heat and moisture. Warmth and moisture move into the lowest part of the atmosphere, according to the NWS.
  3. The air rises. NWS Duluth explains that the warmed air near the water is more buoyant than the cold air above it, so it rises, cools and condenses into clouds.
  4. Bands organize. Clouds line up with the wind. NWS offices in New York describe single bands, multiple bands and small swirling mesovortices.
  5. Snow comes ashore. The wind carries the bands onto land, generally to the south and east of the lakes, NSSL says.

The ingredients forecasters look for

Ingredient What forecasters look for Why it matters
Open water An unfrozen lake Ice cover shuts off the heat and moisture supply
Temperature contrast Lake surface at least 13 degrees Celsius (about 23 degrees Fahrenheit) warmer than the air at the 850-millibar level, a few thousand feet up A bigger contrast means more instability and stronger bands
Fetch A long path over open water; NWS New York offices cite at least 40 miles More time over water adds more heat and moisture
Moisture Enough background water vapor Supports heavier snowfall
Wind Steady direction and enough speed to carry snow inland Decides where bands land and whether they stay put

Source: NWS Milwaukee/Sullivan, NWS Duluth, NWS Grand Rapids and the NWS offices serving New York.

Fetch is the distance the air travels across the water. NWS Grand Rapids says a longer fetch typically produces stronger bands.

Why it piles up in one place and not another

Wind direction is the steering wheel. NWS Grand Rapids calls it “probably the most important factor” for where the heaviest snow falls. Because Lake Michigan runs north to south, southwest Lower Michigan gets lake effect snow when the wind has a westerly component, and the snow stays offshore when the wind turns easterly.

The edges can be startling. In November 2014, NWS Buffalo reported a few inches at one Transit Road intersection and several feet less than 2 miles south, with a band 15 to 20 miles wide that many described as “a wall of snow.”

When a band locks in place, totals soar. NWS Duluth says lake effect events produce huge amounts mainly because the conditions can persist for several days, and NWS offices in New York say the most intense single bands have produced 6 to 7 inches of snow per hour. NWS Buffalo even reported thundersnow in the 2014 and 2022 storms.

Where lake effect snow hits hardest

  • Lake Superior: The south shore across northern Wisconsin and Michigan’s Upper Peninsula, which NWS Duluth calls the Snowbelt region.
  • Lake Michigan: Western Lower Michigan from Ludington to South Haven and inland toward Grand Rapids (NWS Grand Rapids).
  • Lake Erie: The Buffalo metro area with southwest winds, and New York’s Southern Tier with westerly winds, including the I-90 corridor between Buffalo and Erie, Pennsylvania.
  • Lake Ontario: Rochester and Syracuse with west-northwest winds, plus the Tug Hill Plateau, the western Adirondacks and Watertown with westerly or southwesterly winds.

NWS Duluth says lake effect snow can affect places roughly 20 miles inland. In the right setup, the NWS New York offices say it can reach as far as the Hudson Valley.

When is lake effect snow season?

According to the NWS New York offices, the lakes stay warm into fall, so early fall can bring lake effect rain before colder air starts the snow season. In New York, the chance of heavy lake effect snow increases by mid-November and slowly diminishes from mid-February through early March.

Ice ends the season. NOAA Climate.gov explains that once the lakes freeze over and the moisture source is switched off, lake effect snow season comes to an end. Lake Ontario usually sees much less ice than Lake Erie, so lake effect potential lasts longer east of Lake Ontario.

Two historic November examples

November 2014. NWS Buffalo calls the Nov. 17 to 19, 2014, event one of the most significant winter events in Buffalo’s history. More than 5 feet of snow fell just east of the city, with mere inches a few miles north. The agency recorded 14 fatalities, hundreds of major roof collapses and thousands of stranded motorists. A second round on Nov. 19 and 20 added 1 to 4 feet, and totals from the two events peaked at nearly 7 feet.

November 2022. From Nov. 17 to 20, 2022, a long-lived band set up off Lake Erie. NWS Buffalo’s event summary lists a maximum of 81.2 inches near Hamburg and 49 inches off Lake Ontario near West Carthage, with snowfall rates as high as 6 inches per hour. The New York State Thruway was shut down for a period, and a Buffalo Bills home game was moved to Detroit.

Both storms struck in the week before Thanksgiving, a reminder for holiday travelers.

Lake effect snow alerts

The NWS says a Lake Effect Snow Warning is issued when widespread or localized lake induced snow squalls or heavy showers are expected to produce significant snowfall, usually in narrow bands that affect a limited area. A Lake Effect Snow Advisory covers amounts below warning criteria. Criteria vary by office; here is how the New York offices set them.

Alert Typical criteria (New York NWS offices) Typical timing
Winter Storm Watch (lake effect) Heavy lake effect snow possible: 7 inches or more in 12 hours, or 9 inches in 24 hours Typically 2 to 4 days before the event
Lake Effect Snow Warning 7 inches or more in 12 hours, or 9 inches or more in 24 hours (6 and 8 inches in Pennsylvania counties served by NWS Binghamton) Typically 1 to 2 days before the event
Lake Effect Snow Advisory Lake effect snow expected below warning criteria Varies

Source: NWS Winter Weather Warnings, Watches and Advisories; NWS Binghamton winter terminology; NWS Winter Weather Preparedness for New Yorkers: Lake Effect Snow.

For the broader difference between the two alert tiers, see our explainer on what a Winter Storm Watch and a Winter Storm Warning mean. When wind-driven lake snow cuts visibility below a quarter mile for three hours or more, the NWS can issue a Blizzard Warning instead; our guide to how the NWS defines blizzard conditions explains that alert.

Is climate change affecting lake effect snow?

NOAA’s Great Lakes Environmental Research Laboratory says Great Lakes ice cover decreased by about 25 percent from 1973 to 2023. NOAA Climate.gov explains that warmer, longer ice-free lakes could mean more lake effect snow for a while, but over the long term more of it is expected to fall as rain.

How to stay safe

  • Before: Keep an emergency kit at home and in the car, charge phones and test carbon monoxide detectors (NWS New York offices).
  • During: Avoid nonessential travel. If you must drive, slow down and leave more space. Never use a stove, oven or grill for heat, and keep furnace and dryer vents clear of drifts.
  • If stranded: Stay in your vehicle, tie a bright cloth to the antenna or door, run the engine only 10 minutes each hour for heat and keep the exhaust pipe clear of snow.
  • After: Avoid overexertion while shoveling, check for ice dams and frozen pipes, and check on neighbors, especially older people.

Bitter cold often follows the snow, so it helps to know how wind chill works. For active alerts and storm coverage, follow the LiveNewsWorld U.S. Weather Live center.

Frequently asked questions

Can smaller lakes produce lake effect snow?

Large lakes are best, but smaller ones can help. NWS Milwaukee/Sullivan documented a radar band near Madison, Wisconsin, that was enhanced by lake effect processes after cold northwest winds crossed four local lakes.

The bottom line

Lake effect snow is a local, lake-powered storm that can drop feet of snow in one spot and almost nothing a few miles away. In a Great Lakes snowbelt, watch for Lake Effect Snow Warnings from your local NWS office and plan around the bands.

Sources